Two-step log-in: what insurers mean by it
Two-step log-in asks for a second proof, such as a phone prompt, after the password. Insurers usually want it on every staff account and always on admin accounts.
What to do
- Switch it on for admins first.
- Roll it out group by group so nobody is locked out.
- Prefer app prompts over text messages.
- Look for accounts that still skip it, such as shared mailboxes and old service accounts.
Why it matters
Passwords leak. They get reused, guessed or typed into a fake log-in page. With two-step log-in, a stolen password alone is not enough to get in. That is why insurers ask about it first, and why many will not offer cover without it on email and admin accounts.
Not all second steps are equal. An app prompt where the user types a number shown on screen is stronger than a text message. Security keys and passkeys are stronger still and suit admin accounts well.
How to check it yourself
In the Microsoft Entra admin center, the authentication methods area has a report of user registration details. It shows who has registered a second step and which method they use. Anyone without a method is a gap.
Then check what forces the second step. Small companies often use security defaults, which you find under Properties in the Entra admin center. Larger setups use Conditional Access policies instead. If neither is on, users may have registered but are never asked.
Last, look at the sign-in logs for sign-ins that passed with a password only. They show the accounts that slip through.
How to fix it
Also block legacy authentication. Old mail protocols such as POP and IMAP with basic passwords cannot ask for a second step, so an attacker with a password can use them to go around it. A Conditional Access policy can block them, and security defaults do it for you.
- Turn on security defaults if you have no Conditional Access policies. It is one switch and covers everyone.
- If you use Conditional Access, create a policy that requires two-step log-in for all users. Run it in report-only mode first.
- Tell staff before the switch and give them a day to register the Microsoft Authenticator app.
- Block sign-in on shared mailboxes. They should be opened through a person's own account.
- Keep two emergency admin accounts with strong keys, stored safely, for the day something goes wrong.
What to tell your insurer
Say which accounts are covered and how. A clear answer reads like this: all 32 staff accounts and both admin accounts require two-step log-in through the Authenticator app, enforced by a Conditional Access policy. If a service account cannot use it, name it and explain what protects it instead.
How Ciras checks it
With read-only access, Ciras looks at the Microsoft controls that apply to your licences and reports in plain language which accounts are covered and which are not. If you use the AI fix service, it writes each proposed change in plain words, and nothing changes until a person approves it. The next scan shows whether the fix held.
Questions
Is a text message good enough?
It is better than nothing, and some insurers accept it. Text messages can be intercepted or redirected, so an app prompt or a security key is the safer choice.
Do shared mailboxes need two-step log-in?
Nobody should sign in to a shared mailbox directly. Block sign-in on it and give access through each person's own account, which already has two-step log-in.
What about a colleague who loses their phone?
An admin can reset their methods in the Entra admin center so they can register a new phone. Have a short routine for checking it is really them before you do.
Will staff be asked for the second step every time?
No. Once a device is trusted, Microsoft asks again only now and then, or when something about the sign-in looks unusual. How often depends on your settings.