Ciras versus filling in the questionnaire by hand
By hand, you ask people and search settings. With Ciras, the scan asks your systems directly and gives a finished report.
What to do
- By hand: answers depend on who you ask, and gaps get guessed.
- Ciras: every point has an answer, and it is clear what you still confirm.
- By hand: nothing shows whether a fix held.
- Ciras: the next report shows whether a fix held.
What doing it by hand involves
To answer an insurer's questions by hand, someone opens the Microsoft 365 admin center, the Microsoft Entra admin center and the Microsoft Defender portal and looks up each setting. They check admin roles, two-step log-in registrations, Conditional Access policies, email settings and DNS records. Then they ask colleagues and suppliers about backups, training and the incident plan, and put it all into the form.
That works, and for a very small company with someone who knows Microsoft 365 well, it may be all you need. The guides on this site describe where to look for each item.
Where manual answers go wrong
The weak points are rarely skill. They are memory and gaps. People answer what they believe is true: we turned on two-step log-in last year. They may not know about the three accounts that were left out, or the rule someone switched off during a test.
A manual check is also a snapshot. It shows how things looked on the day someone looked, and nothing tells you when a setting changes afterwards. And the answers are only as clear as the person writing them, which makes them hard for a manager to read and sign with confidence.
What Ciras does instead
Ciras logs in with read-only access and asks your Microsoft 365 directly. It checks up to 462 Microsoft security controls; how many apply depends on your licences. The report is ready in about 30 seconds and written in plain language, so the person who signs can follow it.
Some things are not in Microsoft at all: backups outside Microsoft, staff training and a written plan. Ciras puts those in a short form that you confirm and sign. You can see at a glance which answers come from your systems and which come from you.
If you use the optional AI fix service, it proposes changes and writes each one in plain words. It uses a separate permission from the scan, and nothing changes until a person approves. The next scan shows whether the fix held. Your data is stored in the EU, in Stockholm.
If you do it by hand, do it well
- Look in the portals rather than asking from memory, and take a screenshot of each setting with the date.
- Ask suppliers for written answers about backups and access, not a quick yes on the phone.
- Keep the evidence in one folder, so next year's check starts from this year's.
- Have a second person read the answers before anyone signs.
What stays the same
Either way, the company answers the insurer and signs the form. Ciras is not insurance, no insurer has approved it, and it cannot promise what an insurer will decide. The point of both methods is the same: answers that match what your systems show.
Questions
Can we use Ciras and still check things by hand?
Yes, and it is a good idea to spot-check a few items in the admin centers the first time. The other guides on this site say where to look for each one.
Does Ciras change anything when it scans?
No. The scan uses read-only access. Changes only happen through the separate AI fix service, and only after a person approves each one.
What if our licence is small?
Then fewer of the 462 controls apply, because some features only exist on larger licences. The report shows the ones that apply to you.
Will the insurer accept the Ciras report instead of the form?
We cannot say, and you should not assume it. Use the report to answer the insurer's own questions, in the format the insurer asks for.