What a score from 0 to 100 tells you
The score is one number that sums up your checks. A higher number means fewer open problems. It is a starting point for a conversation, not a grade from your insurer.
What to do
- Read the worst problems first.
- Compare with last week's scan.
- Work down the fix list in order.
- Share the score with the people who decide, but do not make it a goal in itself.
Why a single number helps
A list of hundreds of settings is hard to discuss at a management meeting. A score turns it into one number that goes up or down, so you can see whether things are moving in the right direction. It is a useful way to start the conversation and a poor way to end it.
What the number hides
A score weighs many checks together. Two companies with the same number can have very different problems. One may lack two-step log-in for admins, which is serious, while the other is missing a handful of minor settings. Always read the list behind the number.
The checks that count depend on your licences. A company on Microsoft 365 Business Premium has controls in play that a company on Business Basic does not. So comparing your number with another company's says little. Comparing it with your own number last month says much more.
Microsoft has its own score, Microsoft Secure Score, which you find in the Microsoft Defender portal. It uses Microsoft's own weighting and lets admins mark items as handled by another tool or as an accepted risk, which raises the number without changing any setting. Read those marks with care.
How to use the score well
Some items will stay open on purpose. That is fine if someone decided it, wrote down why, and checks again later.
- Start with the problems marked most serious, whatever they do to the number.
- Track the trend over time rather than chasing a target.
- When the number drops, find out why. A new admin, a switched-off rule or a new licence can all move it.
- Do not switch things on just to raise the score. A change that breaks how people work will be undone, and the score will drop again.
What to tell your insurer
A score is not a grade from your insurer, and no insurer has agreed to treat a particular number as a pass. Insurers ask concrete questions, so answer those with the facts behind the score: which accounts have two-step log-in, what your DMARC policy is, where your backups are. The number can go in a covering note if it helps, never in place of the answers.
How Ciras reports it
Ciras checks up to 462 Microsoft security controls with read-only access, and how many apply depends on your licences. The report comes in about 30 seconds and explains in plain language what each open item means. After a fix, the next scan shows whether it held, so you can see the change for yourself rather than take it on trust.
Questions
What is a good score?
One that is rising and has no serious items open. A high number with admin accounts unprotected is worse than a middling one where the basics are in place.
Why did our score change when we did nothing?
Someone else may have changed a setting, a user may have been added, or a new licence may have brought new checks into play. Compare the two reports item by item to find out.
Is our score the same as Microsoft Secure Score?
Not necessarily. Different tools weigh checks differently, so the numbers will rarely match. Look at whether they agree on the open problems, not on the exact figure.
Should we share the score with the board?
Yes, with the trend and the top open items next to it. A number on its own invites the wrong question, which is how to make it go up, instead of which risks are still open.